Comparison between health systems of Indonesia and Singapore: A systematic review
DOI: https://doi.org/10.33024/minh.v8i8.1146
Comparative Health Governance Health System Health Financing Public Health
Abstract
Background: The performance of national health systems is influenced by various internal and external factors, including governance models, financing, and geography. While both Indonesia and Singapore operate mixed public-private healthcare systems, the outcomes and challenges they face vary significantly. Understanding these differences provides critical insight into how contextual factors shape health system effectiveness.
Purpose: To compare the health systems of Indonesia and Singapore by examining their structural components, similarities, differences, and challenges, with a focus on the integration of public health services. The analysis seeks to determine how contextual elements such as governance structure and geographical characteristics influence system performance.
Method: A systematic review with article selection guided by the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines. The systematic review process begins with the formulation of clinical questions relevant to the topic. Before this, the authors establish PICOS criteria, which stand for: P (problem, patient, or population), I (intervention, prognostic factor, or exposure), C (comparison or control), O (outcome), and S (study design). For this article, P: Health systems in southeast asian countries specifically indonesia and singapore. I: Implementation and structure of the health system in Singapore, C: Health system in Indonesia, O: Comparative insights regarding efficiency, equity, accessibility, health outcomes, and quality of care between both countries, S: Systematic Review and Randomized Controlled Trials. The article search was conducted systematically using the keywords: “Health” AND “Workforce,” AND “Record,” “Vaccine Distribution,” AND “Leadership,” AND “Service Delivery,” AND “Financing System,” AND “Information System,” AND “Indonesia” OR “Singapore”.
Results: Singapore’s centralized governance and compact geography enable efficient, integrated healthcare services, leading to superior health outcomes such as higher life expectancy and better physician coverage. In contrast, Indonesia’s decentralized system and geographic dispersion cause fragmented service delivery, resulting in lower life expectancy, fewer healthcare workers, and greater reliance on out-of-pocket spending.
Conclusion: Singapore’s centralized and well-coordinated health system enables efficient service integration and strong health outcomes, while Indonesia’s decentralized structure and vast geography create challenges in achieving equitable and effective healthcare delivery. Strengthening governance, health workforce distribution, and digital health integration are key for Indonesia to enhance its system performance and reduce disparities.
Downloads
References
Aisyah, D. N., Setiawan, A. H., Lokopessy, A. F., Faradiba, N., Setiaji, S., Manikam, L., & Kozlakidis, Z. (2024). The Information And Communication Technology Maturity Assessment At Primary Health Care Services Across 9 Provinces In Indonesia: Evaluation Study. JMIR Medical Informatics, 12, E55959.
Al-Worafi, Y. M. (2020). Drug Safety In Indonesia. In Drug Safety In Developing Countries (Pp. 279-285). Academic Press.
Ang, Y. G. (2023). Development Of The Private Hospitals In Singapore From 1983 To 2022. Journal Of Hospital Management And Health Policy, 7.
Asante, A., Cheng, Q., Susilo, D., Satrya, A., Haemmerli, M., Fattah, R. A., & Wiseman, V. (2023). The Benefits And Burden Of Health Financing In Indonesia: Analyses Of Nationally Representative Cross-Sectional Data. The Lancet Global Health, 11(5), E770-E780.
Azam, M., Islam, F., & Rashid, S. (2024). Health, Environment, And Sustainable Development: Evidence From Panel Data From ASEAN Countries. Air Quality, Atmosphere & Health, 17(4), 827-842.
Basabih, M., Prasojo, E., & Rahayu, A. Y. S. (2022). Hospital Services Under Public-Private Partnerships, Outcomes And, Challenges: A Literature Review. Journal Of Public Health Research, 11(3), 22799036221115781.
Cheng, Q., Asante, A., Susilo, D., Satrya, A., Man, N., Fattah, R. A., & Wiseman, V. (2022). Equity Of Health Financing In Indonesia: A 5-Year Financing Incidence Analysis (2015–2019). The Lancet Regional Health–Western Pacific, 21.
Ekoriano, M., Widiyanto, A., Muthmainnah, M., Devi, Y. P., Cahyono, B. E., Nafsi, I., & Widodo, T. (2025). Profile And Factors Associated With Low Birth Weight In Indonesia: A National Data Survey. Rural And Remote Health, 25(1), 1-9.
Fanda, R. B., Probandari, A., Yuniar, Y., Hendarwan, H., Trisnantoro, L., Jongeneel, N., & Kok, M. O. (2024). The Availability Of Essential Medicines In Primary Health Centres In Indonesia: Achievements And Challenges Across The Archipelago. The Lancet Regional Health-Southeast Asia, 22.
Feng, K., Miranda, A. V., Obnial, J. C., Ebhodaghe, I. D., & Lucero-Prisno III, D. E. (2024). Drug Regulatory Harmonization In The Association Of Southeast Asian Nations: Is It Time For An ASEAN Medicines Agency? A Policy Review. Clinical Epidemiology And Global Health, 28, 101649.
Foo, C. D., Chia, H. X., Tan, S. Y. T., Lai, Y. F., Khoo, J. E. J., Tee, S. Y., & Teo, K. W. (2024). Community Hospitals Of The Future: The Role Of Community Hospitals To Mitigate Health System Burden In Singapore. Frontiers In Health Services, 4, 1407528.
Fuady, A., Anindhita, M., Haniifah, M., Ahsan, A., Sugiharto, A., Haya, M. A. N., & Widyahening, I. S. (2024). Bridging The Gap: Financing Health Promotion And Disease Prevention In Indonesia. Health Research Policy And Systems, 22(1), 146.
Gamalliel, N., & Fuady, A. (2024). Indonesia's New Health Law: Lessons For Democratic Health Governance And Legislation. The Lancet Regional Health-Southeast Asia, 23.
Haemmerli, M., Powell-Jackson, T., Goodman, C., Thabrany, H., & Wiseman, V. (2021). Poor Quality For The Poor? A Study Of Inequalities In Service Readiness And Provider Knowledge In Indonesian Primary Health Care Facilities. International Journal For Equity In Health, 20(1), 239.
Hardhantyo, M., Djasri, H., Nursetyo, A. A., Yulianti, A., Adipradipta, B. R., Hawley, W., & Brye, L. (2022). Quality Of National Disease Surveillance Reporting Before And During COVID-19: A Mixed-Method Study In Indonesia. International Journal Of Environmental Research And Public Health, 19(5), 2728.
Hasanbasri, M., Maula, A. W., Wiratama, B. S., Espressivo, A., & Marthias, T. (2024). Analyzing Primary Healthcare Governance In Indonesia: Perspectives Of Community Health Workers. Cureus, 16(3).
Hermansyah, A., Wulandari, L., Kristina, S. A., & Meilianti, S. (2020). Primary Health Care Policy And Vision For Community Pharmacy And Pharmacists In Indonesia. Pharmacy Practice (Granada), 18(3).
Hossain, M. K., Sutanto, J., Handayani, P. W., Haryanto, A. A., Bhowmik, J., & Frings-Hessami, V. (2025). An Exploratory Study Of Electronic Medical Record Implementation And Recordkeeping Culture: The Case Of Hospitals In Indonesia. BMC Health Services Research, 25(1), 1-20.
Jain, K. D., & Patil, S. B. (2025). Overview Of Medical Device Regulations In Singapore And Thailand. Biomedical Materials & Devices, 3(1), 259-276.
Kharisma, D. B., & Diakanza, A. (2024). Patient Personal Data Protection: Comparing The Health-Care Regulations In Indonesia, Singapore And The European Union. International Journal Of Human Rights In Healthcare, 17(2), 157-169.
Mboi, N., Syailendrawati, R., Ostroff, S. M., Elyazar, I. R., Glenn, S. D., Rachmawati, T., & Mokdad, A. H. (2022). The State Of Health In Indonesia's Provinces, 1990–2019: A Systematic Analysis For The Global Burden Of Disease Study 2019. The Lancet Global Health, 10(11), E1632-E1645.
Meilianti, S., Smith, F., Kristianto, F., Himawan, R., Ernawati, D. K., Naya, R., & Bates, I. (2022). A National Analysis Of The Pharmacy Workforce In Indonesia. Human Resources For Health, 20(1), 71.
Muharram, F. R., Sulistya, H. A., Swannjo, J. B., Firmansyah, F. F., Rizal, M. M., Izza, A., & Romdhoni, A. C. (2024). Adequacy And Distribution Of The Health Workforce In Indonesia. WHO South-East Asia Journal Of Public Health, 13(2), 45-55.
Musadad, D. A., Angkasawati, T. J., Usman, Y., Kelly, M., & Rao, C. (2023). Implementation Research For Developing Civil Registration And Vital Statistics (CRVS) Systems: Lessons From Indonesia. BMJ Global Health, 8(7).
Nisa, K. F., Dompak, T., & Lodan, K. T. (2024, September). Perbandingan Sistem Pelayanan Kesehatan Di Indonesia Dan Di Singapura. In Prosiding Seminar Nasional Ilmu Sosial Dan Teknologi (SNISTEK) (Vol. 6, Pp. 72-77).
Pacific, T. L. R. H. W. (2023). Healthier SG: For A Healthier Singapore And Beyond. The Lancet Regional Health: Western Pacific, 37, 100893.
Paluttri, S. (2024). Comparative Approach In Public Health Social Security: A Legal Case Study Of The Indonesian, France, And Singapore Health Systems. International Journal Of Human Rights In Healthcare, 17(5), 572-587.
Purwatiningsih, A., Lestari, A. W., & Dhuhaniyati, L. (2022). Implications Of Healthcare System In Singapore And Malaysia As Interesting Lessons Towards Primary Service Innovation For Indonesia. Asketik: Jurnal Agama Dan Perubahan Sosial, 6(1), 16-28.
Putra, J. A. D., & Sjaaf, A. C. (2022). Comparison Of The Health Service System And The Universal Health Insurance Among Indonesia's Neighboring Countries. Daengku: Journal Of Humanities And Social Sciences Innovation, 2(4), 502-508.
Raghavan, A., Demircioglu, M. A., & Taeihagh, A. (2021). Public Health Innovation Through Cloud Adoption: A Comparative Analysis Of Drivers And Barriers In Japan, South Korea, And Singapore. International Journal Of Environmental Research And Public Health, 18(1), 334.
Rahman, F. F. (2024). Indonesia’s Healthcare Landscape: Embracing Innovation In The New Health Regime. Current Medical Research And Opinion, 40(6), 929-933.
Ramesh, M., & Qian, J. (2025). Strengthening Primary Care In Singapore: Aligning Vital Health System Components. Policy Design And Practice, 8(1), 50-63.
Rammohan, A., Goli, S., & Chu, H. (2024). Continuum Of Care In Maternal And Child Health In Indonesia. Primary Health Care Research & Development, 25, E17.
Saltman, R. B., Yeh, M. J., & Liu, Y. (2022). Can Asia Provide Models For Tax-Based European Health Systems? A Comparative Study Of Singapore And Sweden. Health Economics, Policy And Law, 17(2), 157-174.
Samarasekera, D. D., Chong, Y. S., Ban, K., Lau, L. S. T., Gallagher, P. J., Zhi Xiong, C., & Lee, S. S. (2024). Transforming Healthcare With Integrated Inter-Professional Education In A Research-Driven Medical School. Medical Teacher, 46(12), 1553-1560.
Sari, N., Omar, M., Pasinringi, S. A., Zulkifli, A., & Sidin, A. I. (2023). Developing Hospital Resilience Domains In Facing Disruption Era In Indonesia: A Qualitative Study. BMC Health Services Research, 23(1), 1395.
See, Q. Y. (2020). Attitudes And Perceptions Of General Practitioners Towards The National Electronic Health Record (NEHR) In Singapore. EMJ, 5(1), 86-93.
Smith, H., Dawes, M., Katzov-Eckert, H., Burrell, S., Xin Hui, S., & Winther, M. D. (2024). Improving Prescribing: A Feasibility Study Of Pharmacogenetic Testing With Clinical Decision Support In Primary Healthcare In Singapore. Family Practice, 41(4), 477-483.
Tan, H. Y., Khamis, N. H., Goh, A., Mah, T. K., Yeo, B., Ngan, J. Y., & Ho, Z. J. M. (2024). Singapore's COVID‐19 Genomic Surveillance Programme: Strategies And Insights From A Pandemic Year. Influenza And Other Respiratory Viruses, 18(12), E70060.
World Health Organization. (2024). Country Cooperation Strategy 2023-2027: Indonesia Continuity And Change. In Country Cooperation Strategy 2023-2027: Indonesia Continuity And Change.
Yang, Y., Venkatachalam, I., Low, C. T., Foo, M. Z. Q., Aung, M. K., See, S. W. J., & Soh, C. R. (2025). Transforming Healthcare System: Outcomes Of Healthier-SG From A Large Tertiary-Care Hospital In Singapore. Health Policy And Technology, 14(1), 100968.
Zainal, H., Quah, J. H., & Smith, H. E. (2022). Experiences Of Doctors Working In Singapore’s Public Primary Healthcare Clinics. Health & Social Care In The Community, 30(5), E1948-E1958.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Rizki Ahmad Nugraha, Indriati Paskarini, Abdul Rohim Tualeka
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
